A: We know the reasons heather is declining in certain areas. Particular reasons
include increased fertility from birch leaves, invasion of scrub and birch woodland
along with increased use of traffic through the heather, particularly the ease
with which electric buggies go through the rough.
To restore heather we need to eliminate the causes of the decline by removing
scrub and birch woodland as well as trying to route traffic away from heather
areas. However to restore it drastic action is required. This involves complete
stripping of the built up organic matter from above the mineral layer by mechanical
means. This involves hiring machinery to undertake the task. Walton Heath Golf
Club for example hired a machine dedicated to this task at a cost of in excess
of £400 per day and that was a fair few years ago. This is to expose the seed
bank that is in the last 5mm or so of this layer. Heather seed can remain viable
for between 40 and 60 years. Regeneration is not always guaranteed and it can
take up to 3 years for results to show. Areas that do not naturally regenerate
can have brashings containing seed spread over them. The Conservators have had
a lot of success on the forest using this method.
At RAFGC a number of areas out of play have come back very successfully after
just scraping off the top layer. Piltdown Golf Club have successfully re-established
large areas by complete removal of trees and the organic layer above the subsoil
and fencing off to keep feet and trolleys out.
This area at the top of the Old Course a few years ago, as can be seen above,
was nothing but bracken and birch scrub with a thick layer of organic matter on
it. It was all scraped off down to the subsoil. After 12 months there were very
few heather seedlings showing. After a further 12 months things were more encouraging
with more seedling coming up. In the third year all changed with the area nearly
completely covered in heather.
As can be seen it looks very different after 3 years with little tufts of scrub
gorse showing through. These have to be regularly topped to stop them taking over
and smothering the heather.
This is a different area of approximately 1 acre in no mans land between the
8th and 12th fairway on the Old Course. Stripped of its vegetation in the winter
of 2003, this is what it looks like today. This is where the heather turf was
taken from for the patch on the right hand side of the 12th green. Unfortunately
it is very difficult to cut as turf because of the large amount of shale and sandstone
beneath the surface. (29/03/07)
Q: There seems to be quite a lot of moss appearing in the fairways. Can we
not treat it?
A: We could, however the cost would be very high, in excess of £7400 per chemical
treatment! It is quite normal for moss to show at the start of spring. Grass growth
has been weak or non existent during the winter months giving the moss little
competition. As soon as the grass starts growing in earnest and the dryer months
come along it will rapidly disappear. Interestingly enough there is less moss
present this year than there has been in previous years. Moss, like heather, hates
being trodden on so a little trick used on the greens is to place the pin in or
near a moss patch and then the players feet wear it away. The mainly organic fertilisers
used on the greens in the spring contain iron which rapidly kills off any moss.
The green approach! (27/03/07)
Q: I have noticed that there has been a lot of yellowing of the grass in some
places. What causes this?
A: It is caused by the cranefly larvae eating the roots of the grass. There
were a lot of craneflies last autumn and the conditions for their eggs to hatch
were perfect. Each cranefly can lay over 300 eggs into the surface of the turf.
This has been the worst infestation we have ever seen here, with literally hundreds
to a square metre. Fortunately there is a very effective chemical control and
all greens and other infected areas have been treated. If left unchecked, some
areas would be left completely bare, devoid of all grass cover. However there
is also another pest at work within the soil which is the larvae of the fever
fly or St. Marks fly as it is sometimes known. This again is a small grub that
eats the grass roots causing the yellowing symptoms. These particular bugs are
normally only found in small quantities, but because of the conditions this winter they
have survived in large numbers. The bad news is there is no chemical control for
this pest and we have to hope that the damage will not be too great. Fortunately
it is limited to a few areas and an acidic fertiliser will be applied today to
make conditions as unpleasant as possible for the grubs. (08/03/07)
Q: Why is it that when the greens start to grow, for a time, they become very
uneven and bumpy?
A: This is because there are more than one species of grass within them, different
species grow at different rates. Some start growing at slightly lower temperatures
than others. Some species have deeper roots than others, so they are in soil that
has not warmed yet and therefore do not start to grow until warmth gets down to
that depth. The greens are predominately a mixture of agrostis, fescue and poa.
Poa being the weed species that no one wants but a lot of courses end up with!
This is the species that produces all the little seed heads in the spring which
also causes unevenness. (08/03/07)
Q: Why is it that after the winter the course takes so long for the greens
to fill and the grass to grow whereas other courses seem to come on much quicker?
A: For grass to actively grow there are a number of requirements. Moisture,
daylight, nutrients and temperature. Without all four, grass will not respond.
Adding more of any one of the elements without all four being present will make
no difference. By mid March there is enough daylight. Nutrient and moisture could
be applied but for one factor, the soil temperature is too low. It does not matter
how warm the air is during the day. What counts is the temperature of the medium
in which the roots of the plant sit. A warm afternoon is easily outweighed by
an overnight frost. Ten degrees Celsius is normally seen as the minimum for a
few days, to start growth. But we now have a further problem in the fact that
the wetter the soil, the slower it is to warm up. This is one of the reasons that
irrigation is never used until the soil warms up as it would work against us.
All courses are on differing types of soil. A sandy soil warms up much faster
than a clay soil, because it contains less moisture, which is the reason that
early season potatoes and strawberries are grown on the sandy soils of Norfolk
and Lincolnshire. Conversely when the greens on other courses are past their best
our greens can still be putting beautifully late into the autumn. (06/03/07)
Q: The course has suffered from being very wet this winter. What impact does
the removal of a large numbers of trees have upon this?
A: None whatsoever. Deciduous trees only take up water when actively growing,
so when dormant in winter with no leaves take up no water at all. Conifers, although
they retain their leaves, become dormant as well and take up little moisture.
Q: Why is it that the 2nd tee on the Old Course is in such a poor state during
the winter months?
A: The answer to that is that it receives virtually no direct sunlight because
of the cover from the trees in the property next to it. For grass to survive it
needs at least 6 hours of sunlight each day, so with the sun so low in the winter
time it receives very little light. The West Course putting lawn was constructed
at the same time as the 16th green using the same batch of turf and the same construction
materials. The putting green is looking very well in January whereas the 16th
green looks very sad. Again it is down to lack of light due to shading. It very
much the same situation with the huge modern stadia with their stands blocking
light. Many stadia have to be returfed every 12 weeks or so at a cost of over
£80,000!
Q: Would it be a good idea for golfers to carry bio degradable divot anchors
so they can anchor their divots down once they have replaced them?
A: The problem with them is that even if the divots were anchored down the
birds will pull the ends up looking for food. If divots are anchored down in the
summer months they would die anyway as they do not have enough root to take up
what little moisture there is. We then have the scenario of dead, brown divots
which will have to be individually picked up. It would not be possible for a sweeper to
pick them up.
Q: Why is it not possible to lower the height of cut on the greens to increase
the speed?
A: It is, but it does not last very long. Too much leaf is removed and the
plant can no longer produce enough food to live. Mowing at a height of 3 mm for
any length of time measured in days rather than weeks creates excessive stress
and the grass dies. Thus the age old term the quick and the dead. The recognised
way to increase green speed is to increase the height of cut to encourage the finer species of grasses and to regularly
roll the greens. This comes at a cost in terms of equipment and particularly labour.
The excellent R&A website outlines the sustainable route and we have been
actively working at achieving this by signing up to the scheme. Poa dominated
greens can be made very fast but unfortunately require massive inputs of water,
fertiliser and chemicals. Encouraging the finer grasses does not happen overnight
but as has been proven in Denmark, since all chemicals were banned there a number
of years ago, it certainly works.
Q: Why is it that some times the West Course is closed but the Old remains
open?
A: Size is quite a large factor. The putting surfaces, the tees and the fairways on
the Old are double the area of the West, so it is much easier to spread wear. The
Old naturally drains better than the West for many reasons. One huge factor is
that the West from hole 7 through to hole 16 is the site of a WW1 army training
camp which had 3000 troops stationed upon it. With their respective horses it
became churned up for the 4 years they were on it. When the army left the site
in 1919 they merely levelled out what was there, leaving concrete, footings and
old broken drains buried below. All soil structure was destroyed along with any
natural drainage. Another consideration is the fact that the West was built on
a very small budget and for 25 years was completely abandoned whereas the Old
was still having improvements and maintenance. To drain the West would be a very
expensive operation but something that will be undertaken when funds permit.
Q: How much maintenance does the course machinery require?
A: The answer to that is, a lot. Apart from routine servicing throughout the
year each machine has to undergo a complete winter overhaul. Modern greenkeeping
machinery has become very sophisticated with on board computers and monitoring
systems that need to be maintained. All cutters are stripped to their component
parts and checked for wear and damage. All cutting edges are reground accurately,
all parts painted and worn items replaced with new ones. All fluids are replaced
and the machine is then reassembled and the work undertaken is written up in a
machinery logbook. This work normally takes David, our mechanic, 3 months solid
work. All ride on vehicles are given a comprehensive service and any worn parts
replaced. All this is to minimise breakdowns and ensure that the machine works
at its most efficient.
Q: Why is it some greens are wetter than others?
A: As with most things there are a number of reasons for this, soil type,
topography, shade and foot traffic. The greens on both courses are what is known
as push up greens. This means they were made by pushing up together whatever soil
was on the site of the green. Thus the soil type will vary from green to green
with a differing infiltration rate. There is no topsoil as such just a very silty
subsoil with about 25mm of accumulated top dressing on top. In fact when I have
shown people what lies beneath the turf they are quite amazed that the grass grows
at all. Any drainage is only as fast as the water can penetrate the underlying
soil. You could put as many pipes as you like underneath but it would still drain
at the same rate. A modern green would be constructed using a purpose made rootzone
designed to drain easily. Where there is heavy cover from trees this stops sunlight
getting to the green surface and also impedes air movement. Where a green has
bumps and hollows this again allows a build up of standing water. Foot traffic
in the walk off areas causes compaction when wet which leads to surface puddling.
Q: With all the talk of global warming should we not be planting trees rather
than cutting them down and should we not burn them when we do?
A: Trees do take carbon dioxide out of the air and lock it up within the tree. However
they can only do this when actively growing with leaves on them. For 6 months
of the year they are not removing any carbon dioxide at all whilst they have no
leaves. Grass however keeps ticking over all the year round, fixing carbon within
the plant, only becoming dormant in very cold conditions. As for burning the remains,
yes it does release carbon dioxide into the atmosphere, but it is the same carbon
dioxide it took out of the atmosphere in the first place whilst growing, so in
effect it is carbon neutral. If the tree died naturally it would still release
the same carbon dioxide as it decomposed. The only net increase in carbon dioxide
is from the burning of fossil fuels which have locked up the carbon within them
many millions of years ago.
Q: Would it not help drainage if sand were put down on the wet areas?
A: In a word, no. Sand on wet areas can for a very short time stop mud sticking
to trolley wheels and feet. To understand why it will not help we need to know
about particle size. These are the individual particles of clay, silt and sand.
The individual grains of sand will have a relatively large space between each
of them but clay and silt are very fine and very mobile when wet. Any water flowing
into the spaces between the sand would very rapidly be filled by the clay and
silt particles carried by its flow, thus impeding any movement of the water once
all the spaces are filled. Also filling hollow tine holes with sand will just
give a sand filled hole full of water as the water has nowhere to go once it reaches
the bottom of the hole. An old greenkeeping adage is that clay and sand make bricks!
Q. Why is it necessary for the course to be closed in very wet weather?
A. When very wet all the soil particles become mobile i.e. the water acts
as a lubricant allowing them to slide over one another. When the ground becomes
saturated feet push down the turf into the soil. Very soon the soil has worked
its way on top of the turf and the turf dies. Remember it is the roots that bind
the soil together so all sorts of erosion problems are caused. Surface levels
are easily damaged causing greens to become bumpy. The surface can become very
smeared which in turn has a very detrimental effect on water draining from the
surface. Different areas are affected in different ways depending on the clay
content of the soil, which can vary greatly from one area to another. In the winter
months very little if any water is being taken up by the roots so that it takes
less rain to cause a problem than it would in the drier summer months.
Q. Why is the amount of heather on the course in decline?
A. Mainly because of the way we now play golf. We play all winter taking great
heavy power caddies through the heather. If there is one thing heather hates it
is being walked on or rolled down. On any hole on the course where there is heather
in the rough nowhere is it in greater decline than where the majority of errant
drives land. Heather hates being shaded and the amount of shade caused by birch
invasion has an effect. Heather likes infertility, but birch leaves in autumn
increase the fertility of the soil. Gorse is a legume and as such fixes atmospheric
nitrogen into the soil, again increasing fertility.
Q. Why is it some times the greens are topdressed after spiking and not other
times? Surely it helps smooth the surface?
A. This depends on what type of spiking was carried out. If it is hollow tining,
where a core of soil is removed then it is good practice to work some dressing
down into the holes. When using solid tines however, the soil around the hole
is displaced and has to be allowed to settle back. If the hole were filled this
would not happen and the ground would remain compacted.
Q. How often are the greens cut and at what height?
A. In the main growing season from mid may until the end of September they
are cut every day unless weather conditions dictate otherwise. For the rest of
the year, as necessary. In summertime the height of cut will go down to 4.5 millimetres
rising to 6 millimetres during the winter.
Q. Why do you top dress, how often, and what does it consist of?
A. Top dressing is a way of smoothing the surface and helps make the greens
true. Over a period of time it helps improves the quality of the topsoil. Normally
the greens will be topdressed 6 times per year. There are many types of top dressing
and different ones suit different courses. It all depends what the greens were
built out of. The top dressing used here consists of 70% silt free round grained
washed Sevenoaks sand and 30% Fenland alluvial soil.
Q. At certain times of the year, particularly in the spring, the holes become
crowned. What causes this?
A. Frankly, it is your feet! When the ground is soft which it is in the spring
with virtually no growth and having had the winter rain and frost to contend with.
The most used area of the green is obviously the hole with all feet headed in
that direction. The bit that makes it worse is the leading foot 6 inches from
the hole with all your body weight resting on it, pushing the surface down, as
you retrieve your ball, causing the last 6 inches to be higher than the piece
your foot is on.